Now,
don’t get me wrong: the truth is that there’s no sure way to avoid an IRS
audit. However, there are some red flags that can shield you from unwanted
attention from the IRS.
I have seen a lot of
people freak out every April. The problem? Taxes! As a matter of fact, I knew a
lot of Americans who would rather have root canal surgery than an Internal
Revenue Service (IRS) audit. They are not entirely wrong. I mean, we hear the
stories all the time from relatives, neighbors, friends or friends of friends, and
even wealthy politicians and celebrities getting caught up with the tax man for
not reporting, inaccurate reporting or underreporting
their incomes on their tax returns. When things like this happens, the people
involved either pay stiff penalties to the IRS or are sent to jail over bad tax
reporting. And if the people affected this way are celebrities, politicians or
wealthy people, it can become a major news that instills fears over an IRS agent showing up on our own doorstep. Ideally,
that’s exactly how the IRS wants it: fear increases compliance. But, in spite
of that, the agency doesn’t really want to put people in jail for the simple
reason that they benefit more when taxpayers are out there working and bringing
in more revenue.
I still remember the day
I came back from work and saw a thick white envelope from the IRS in my
mailbox. At first I was too scared to open it. Jesus H. Christ! What have I
done this time? Am I being audited? Later on, I tied my courage to the post and
opened it. It wasn’t that bad: it was about a little money I made from winning
a second position in a national essay in 2014. I forgot to report this income
in my tax return and the letter stated that I owed taxes on that income plus
the penalty that was applied. Not a big deal: I made a payment arrangement with
IRS and paid it off. End of story.
But for some people, it
could be too bad. Even the legendary mob boss Alfonse Capone was sent to jail
for tax evasion.1 So it is not surprising that a lot of people get
heart palpations whenever they receive a letter from the IRS. One thing is for
certain: whatever your tax problems, don’t be scared. There will always be a safe resolution provided that you
are willing to work with IRS to meet their deadlines. It is important, though,
to understand why IRS may be interested in eyeballing your tax return.
4
Big IRS red flags that could lead to tax audit
Without putting it in so
many words, the only reason to worry about IRS audit is if you are fudging on
your taxes or if you are not paying your taxes. The IRS is short on personnel
and funding and, as a result, they audited only 0.86% of all individual returns
in 2014.2 In 2015, they
audited about 0.84% of returns while in 2016 IRS audited only 0.70% of all individual
tax returns.3 So, as you can see, the chances that your return will
be singled out for review is pretty low. While there’s no sure way to avoid an
IRS audit, the following red flags may attract them to you.
If
you make a lot of money
Generally speaking, the
overall individual audit rate is only about one in 143 tax returns. However,
your chances of attracting IRS examination of your tax returns increase
dramatically as your income goes up. According to IRS statistics for 2016, if
your income is $200,000 per year or higher, then your chances of being audited
by the IRS is 1.01%, or about one out of every 60 returns; and you have a roughly 1 in 5 chance of getting
audited if you earn $10 million or more(see table 1).4 Now, I’m not
trying to discourage you from making more money.
Table 1: Percentage of
Individual Returns Audited in 2016
|
Size of Adjusted
Gross Income
|
Returns Audited
|
|
No adjusted
gross income
|
3.25%
|
|
Under $25,000
|
0.80%
|
|
$25,000 -
$49,999
|
0.49%
|
|
$50,000 -
$74,999
|
0.41%
|
|
$75,000 -
$99,999
|
0.52%
|
|
$100,000 -
$199,999
|
0.62%
|
|
$200,000 -
$499,999
|
1.01%
|
|
$500,000 -
$999,999
|
2.06%
|
|
$1,000,000 -
$4,999,999
|
4.60%
|
|
$5,000,000 -
$9,999,999
|
10.46%
|
|
10,000,000 or
more
|
18.79%
|
Source:
Internal Revenue Service Data Book, 2016
Like everyone else, you
definitely want to be rich. But it is important to understand that you are more
likely to hear from IRS if more income shows up in your tax return.
Failure
to report all income on tax return
You are required by law
to report all the income you earned in a given year to the IRS on an annual tax
return. In any case, the IRS also receive copies of all of the 1099s and W-2s that
you receive so don’t think you can outsmart them. So you can imagine what would
happen if you did not report all required income in your return. Now, because
the IRS computers are very good at matching the numbers on the forms with the
income shown on your return, any mismatch will immediately light up a red flag.
And this will cause the IRS computers to spit out a bill.5 If, for some reason you receive a 1099 listing
incorrect income, or a 1099 that shows income that isn’t yours, contact the
issuer immediately and get them to file a correct form to the IRS. This way you
can avoid unnecessary headaches and penalties.
Are
your tax deductions too big?
You could be flirting
with IRS audit if the deductions on your return are disproportionately large
compared with an income. Here’s a better way of putting this: if you are
claiming out sized deductions it will raise red flags and the IRS may pull your
return for review. So be sure to have the proper documentation for your
deductions. If you do this, then you shouldn’t be afraid to claim them.
If
you are running a small business
Most small business
owners and self-employed individuals know that Schedule C is a treasure trove
of tax deductions. But what a lot of them don’t know is that Schedule C is also
a gold mine for the IRS agents. It is important to state here that IRS agents
are very smart people, and they know from experience that self-employed people
sometimes claim excessive deductions and don’t report all their incomes. The
IRS agents are like the ‘middle school principal’ that watches over both the higher-grossing sole proprietorship
and smaller ones.
Some businesses are
called cash-intensive businesses because they receive significant amount of
their incomes in cash. Good examples are taxis, restaurants, hair salons, car
washes, bars, and so on.6 If you own that type of business you will
receive special scrutiny from IRS especially if you report a substantial net
loss on Schedule C.
Each
to their own
Next time you get those
envelopes, don’t get scared. Just stay calm and remember there’s always a safe
resolution. And as a taxpayer you have your rights. Take a deep breath and know
that you don’t have to fear being bullied or confused by the IRS. Keep in mind
that you can get some help if you need it. For example, Taxpayer Advocate is an
independent organization within the IRS that have vowed to help taxpayers like
you resolve their tax problems.
References
1Crime lord Al Capone,
Known As Scarface, is Found Guilty for Tax Evasion in 1931. (2016, October 17).
New York Daily News. Retrieved April 24, 2017 from http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/crime-lord-al-capone-found-guilty-tax-evasion-1931-article-1.2833965
2Tax Debt Help(2015). IRS Audit Statistics: Rates and Chances of
Receiving A Tax Audit. Retrieved April 25, 2017 from http://www.taxdebthelp.com/tax-problems/tax-audit/irs-audit-statistics
3Taylor J.(2017). 17 Red
Flags for IRS Auditors. Kiplinger.
Retrieved April 25, 2017 from http://www.kiplinger.com/slideshow/taxes/T056-S011-red-flags-that-can-raise-your-irs-audit-risk/index.html
4Bell K.(2017). 2017 Tax
Guide. Bank Rate. Retrieved April 25,
2017 from http://www.bankrate.com/finance/taxes/red-flags-that-tempt-the-tax-auditor-1.aspx
5Taylor, op. cit., para. 3
6Internal Revenue
Service(n. d.). Cash Intensive Business
Audit Techniques. Retrieved April 26, 2017 from https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-utl/cashchapter1_210627.pdf